background preloader

Neo-tribalism

Facebook Twitter

Agriculture as "Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race"? Jared Diamond’s breakthrough 1987 article, “Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race” claims agriculture did not deliver the splendors of civilization but was instead a highway to hell. This section examines the traditional progressivist perspective on agriculture and the sources for Diamond’s revisionism, including passages that seem plagiarized from earlier anthropological work. For more on the perspective anthropology brings, see What is Anthropology? This section is an introduction to an archaeology and anthropological investigation of domestication, hunting-and-gathering, agriculture, and the rise of state government.

It is impossible to consider these issues without tackling the writings of Jared Diamond, whose works on agriculture and its implications for modern life are very widely read, influential with powerful people like Bill Gates. For more on human nature, evolution, and race see my Kindle e-Book: Agriculture, Traditional View: Progressivist Watershed Moment. . (1991). Savaging Primitives: Why Jared Diamond’s “The World Until Yesterday” is Completely Wrong. I ought to like this book: after all, I have spent decades saying we can learn from tribal peoples, and that is, or so we are told, Jared Diamond’s principal message in his new “popular science” work, The World Until Yesterday. But is it really? Diamond has been commuting for 50 years between the U.S. and New Guinea to study birds, and he must know the island and some of its peoples well.

He has spent time in both halves, Papua New Guinea and Indonesian‐occupied West Papua. He is in no doubt that New Guineans are just as intelligent as anyone, and he has clearly thought a lot about the differences between them and societies like his, which he terms Western, educated, industrialized, rich, and democratic (“WEIRD”). He calls the latter “modern.” Had he left it at that, he would have at least upset only some experts in New Guinea, who think his characterizations miss the point. This is nonsense. How much of this actually is fact, and how much just personal opinion?

Really? Survival International - The movement for tribal peoples. Jared Diamond's new book 'The World Until Yesterday' slammed by Survival. Diamond says that state governments stop tribal people from killing each other, but doesn't mention that an estimated 100,000 Papuans have been killed by the Indonesian authorities. © Jeanne Herbert/Survival Tribal rights organization Survival International has launched a vigorous critique of Pulitzer Prize-winner Jared Diamond’s new book ‘The World Until Yesterday: What Can We Learn from Traditional Societies?’

, labelling it ‘dangerous nonsense,’ which, if believed, risks ‘pushing the advancement of human rights for tribal peoples back decades.’ In an article published by the US publication Daily Beast entitled ‘Savaging Primitives: Why Jared Diamond’s “The World Until Yesterday” is completely wrong’, Survival’s Director Stephen Corry attacks two of Diamond’s main messages: that today’s tribal peoples are a model of how everyone lived until a few thousand years ago (in a ‘world until yesterday’); and that tribal societies are more violent than industrialized societies.

Note to editors. Jared Diamond in row over claim tribal peoples live in 'state of constant war' Jared Diamond photographed at home in Los Angeles with some Guinean artefacts. Photograph: Steve Schofield for the Observer A fierce dispute has erupted between Pulitzer prize-winning author Jared Diamond and campaign group Survival International over Diamond's recently published and highly acclaimed comparison of western and tribal societies, The World Until Yesterday: What Can We Learn from Traditional Societies? The controversy threatens to expose a deep rift in modern anthropology, with each claiming the other has fallen into a delusion that threatens to undermine the chances for survival of the world's remaining tribal societies. On a book tour of the UK last week, Diamond, 75, was drawn into a dispute with the campaign group after its director, Stephen Corry, condemned Diamond's book as "completely wrong – both factually and morally – and extremely dangerous" for portraying tribal societies as more violent than western ones.

But Survival remains adamant. Mistake. The absence of war. War creates curious kinds of invitations to anthropology. In the early days of the Iraq invasion, many newspapers published commentaries about the nature and character of war. Lurking behind such writing are questions about human nature. Have we evolved from peaceful into warlike creatures? Or did homo sapiens begin with some kind of enthusiasm for killing one another, hardwired into our very origins? Those asking and seeking to answer these questions often turn their eyes towards the “primitive”, supposing that there we can find our original selves. Or can they? The difficulty with this kind of anthropological evidence is both simple and complicated. We are all contemporaries But the more difficult problem about the use of this kind of evidence lies in whether or not it could ever be right.

The answer is both no and yes. The answer is no, because everyone in the world has been evolving for the same amount of time. Crossing the fence. Endemic warfare. Endemic warfare is the state of continual, low-threshold warfare in a tribal warrior society. Warfare is known to several tribal societies, but some societies develop a particular emphasis of warrior culture (such as the Nuer of Sudan,[1] the Māori of New Zealand, the Yanomamö (dubbed "the Fierce People") of the Amazon,[2] or the Germanic tribes of Iron Age Europe). [citation needed] Endemic warfare is not equivalent to "primitive warfare" in general, but is reserved for perpetual low-threshold conflicts.

Communal societies are well capable of escalation to all-out wars of annihilation between tribes. Thus, in Amazonas, there was perpetual animosity between the neighboring tribes of the Jivaro. A fundamental difference between wars enacted within the same tribe and against neighboring tribes is such that "wars between different tribes are in principle wars of extermination".[3] The Yanomamö of Amazonas traditionally practiced a system of escalation of violence in several discrete stages. NeoTribalist Films. The Friends Of Ishmael Society. Read Ishmael by Daniel Quinn. Cultural Survival | Partnering with Indigenous Peoples to Defend their Lands, Languages, and Cultures.

Ishmael.org.