Usage-based insurance. Illinois car insurance rates in this study are based on our analysis of data and information from the illinois department of insurance and quadrant information services. Overall, we think geico is the best choice for illinois car insurance because of its reputation for quick claims, high customer satisfaction in illinois, and low average cost. The operator of this website is not an insurance broker or an insurance company, is not a representative or an agent to any broker or insurance company, does not endorse any particular broker or insurance provider and does not make any insurance decisions. Before you start comparing auto insurance quotes, take another look at our top three providers for cheap car insurance in illinois. In the article, she discusses all aspects of our transformation program and the ways pekin insurance is leading digital change in the insurance industry in order to grow our business and improve the overall customer experience and ease of doing business.