Cheapest rates. To help drivers find the best cheap auto insurance in indiana, our editorial team collected quotes from top car insurance companies across every zip code in the state. We have gathered price quotes from all the major insurance providers in indiana and put together a list of the cheapest car insurance companies. Asking your agent or insurance company about money-saving discounts or usage-based insurance can help you lower your overall insurance costs, such as a safe driver or multi-policy discounts from life, rental, or home insurance policies. Lemonade insurance agency and lemonade insurance company hold agreements among them in which lemonade insurance company pays lemonade, inc. Auto insurance companies will provide you the auto insurance quotes to you. Our first choice for indiana car insurance is geico, while our runner-up picks are erie insurance, usaa, country financial, and farmers.