Coverage limits. We compare car insurance rates for over 150 different cars, trucks, and suvs to find the cheapest indianapolis auto insurance quotes. Check out the market shares, loss ratios, and direct written premiums for the top 10 car insurance companies in indiana. From liability protection to comprehensive coverage, we customize your indiana auto insurance, so you only pay for what you need. If this is the case, you can apply for the indiana auto insurance plan through any insurance agent in the state. Indiana drivers can get great prices on car insurance from usaa, progressive, and american family insurance. Take your time to shop around for an insurance policy and you can get excellent coverage at a fair price while meeting indiana's legal requirements. Carmel, fishers, and fort wayne are other cities in indiana with the lowest average rates for auto insurance.