Premium. Can your credit score have an impact on your car insurance premium? Almost all providers offer discounts, and you may even be eligible for multiple discounts that can, collectively, make a nice dent in your premium. Illinois has extremely harsh penalties for driving without auto insurance. Farmers lloyds insurance company of texas, economy preferred insurance company, or economy fire and casualty insurance company, all with administrative home offices in warwick, ri. How much does auto insurance cost in illinois? Is auto insurance cheaper in missouri or illinois? Geico had the lowest auto insurance cost for adding a driver age 16 to a full coverage family policy, among insurers surveyed. We explain illinois car insurance laws and provide average illinois auto insurance rates for your neighborhood. To help teen drivers find cheap illinois car insurance, we compared quotes for a full coverage policy from seven car insurance companies.