Insurance companies. S a look at average monthly quotes for the cheapest car insurance in indiana based on driving and accident history. Cost of car insurance in indiana vs. S take a closer look at how zip codes affect car insurance in indiana. If your car is in the shop due to a covered event, your insurance company will reimburse you for the cost of a rental vehicle up to a certain amount. What is the best auto insurance company in indiana? U003ethere are quite a few factors that go into determining the cost of your auto insurance premiums, such as your age, driving record and the type of car you drive.