Sr-22. Car insurance companies use your insurance score to determine your car insurance premium. Progressive, safeauto, nationwide, and the general insurance are the cheapest auto insurance companies in indiana. When searching and comparing quotes from the best auto insurance companies in indiana, it can be frustrating trying to understand how your insurance rates are calculated. But while price is an important consideration for most drivers when choosing a car insurance company, there are other factors to consider. In addition to factors like your age, gender, motor vehicle history, location, credit-based insurance score and claims history, certain life events can also cause your car insurance premium to increase. Many insurance professionals recommend these coverage types, however, to give you financial protection in the event that you are hit by someone who lacks an auto insurance policy or has limited coverage.