2016 is now all about the Supreme Court: This is how Justice Scalia’s death deadlocks the Court — and changes presidential race. What are the legal and political implications of Antonin Scalia’s sudden death?
First, in regard to the legal status of all cases currently before the Supreme Court, all of Scalia’s votes on those cases no longer count. Justices cast their initial votes on cases in a conference, and the task of writing the majority opinion is assigned to a particular justice. Drafts of this opinion then circulate among those justices who voted in the majority, for comments and potential revisions. But until the decision is formally issued, any justice is free to change the vote he or she cast in the conference. Antonin Scalia obituary: conservative supreme court justice dies aged 79. Antonin Scalia, a supreme court justice who has died aged 79, relished his position as a bulwark resisting the social changes sweeping America over a generation.
The former law professor was fiercely and flamboyantly conservative on “culture wars” issues from abortion and gay marriage to gun laws and capital punishment. He believed the constitution should be a fixed point in a changing world. It made him a bête noire of liberals and progressives and a sitting target for satirists such as Jon Stewart. Nicknamed “Nino”, the devout Catholic was proud to be the first Italian American on the supreme court. The Worst Opinions of Antonin Scalia. The most conservative justice in recent memory will be judged rather harshly by history Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia has passed away at the age of 79.
Some may say it’s time to mourn the man who served on the highest court for 30 years, and not criticize his work, but I have no intention of letting Scalia off the hook that easily while he is still in the spotlight. I had nothing but contempt for this man of justice while he was alive, I will certainly not change my judgement of him now that he is gone. Mourn the man if you wish, but I will not grieve for a guy that has given so many progressives grief. Justice Antonin Scalia’s Anti-Church/State Separation Legacy. Thank you for your interest in Patheos newsletters!
Please enter your email address below and click the "Subscribe" button. Thank you for your subscription. You can visit your Preference Center to complete your profile and see what else we have to offer. We apologize, we were unable to complete your subscription at this time, please try again later. The Timely Passing of Antonin Scalia. The death of the the most conservative judge on the Supreme Court just made the 2016 Election that much more important Antonin Scalia had been on the Supreme Court since 1986, and he had been one of the most conservative judges on the bench.
Among his worst rulings, Scalia gave us a Bush win in the 2000 election over Al Gore and Citizens United. He had also fought hard against a range of progressive issues, from gay marriage to birth control. Scalia had been a rather troublesome character for progressives to say the least. But now that Antonin Scalia has passed, an interesting dynamic now shadows the 2016 election: whoever wins the election replaces Scalia and will control the court.
Antonin Scalia: a supreme court justice 'extreme and out of step' with women. It would be an understatement to note that Justice Antonin Scalia, who passed away on Saturday, was a controversial figure.
Known for his acerbic dissents and what President Obama called a “larger than life presence on the bench”, the supreme court justice’s death immediately provoked discussion on how soon is too soon to note the way a public person’s career negatively impacted so many. Given Scalia’s penchant for disagreement and unapologetically saying what you think, however, it seems unlikely that he’d take issue with the American people doing the same in the wake of his passing. And the truth is that throughout Scalia’s long tenure on the supreme court, he crafted a legacy that was decidedly regressive and anti-woman. Scalia was a proponent of originalism, believing that the constitution’s meaning is fixed, and should be interpreted in the way the framers originally intended. “Certainly the constitution does not require discrimination on the basis of sex,” Scalia said.
What Scalia stood against: A government that helped the less well off. The text of the 15th Amendment could not be clearer—“The rights of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by any state.
The Congress shall have the power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.” For a true and honest textualist and originalist the answer to the question regarding the constitutionality of Section 5 of the Voting Right Act was a clear and easy one—it is constitutional. But if you have interests you value above your stated principles of judicial interpretation—for example, your hatred of government remedies to address racial discrimination—those “sacred principles” must fall by the wayside. And in Shelby County, Scalia served his highest calling—his hatred for government remedies to address racial discrimination.
As Scott Lemieux describes, Antonin Scalia was the very embodiment of the hard-right conservative Republican Id—expressing the hatred and contempt the Republican Party has for non “Real Americans.” Scalia's death could deal Republicans a huge blow in upcoming redistricting and voting rights cases. More immediately, the court was set to decide two cases, one in North Carolina and one in Virginia, where district courts have partially struck down Republican-drawn congressional maps on the grounds that map-makers improperly relied on race when drawing the lines.
Republicans had appealed the Virginia ruling, and the Supreme Court was set to hear oral arguments on March 31, but without a Republican majority, the lower court ruling is very unlikely to be disturbed. That means Democrats will be all but guaranteed to pick up a seat, as black voters will likely gain another representative under the remedial map approved by the district court. Meanwhile, North Carolina’s congressional map was struck down on similar grounds, and the district court in that case ordered Republican lawmakers to implement new lines by Feb. 19. » Justice Scalia legacy on religion: A look at the last year of his life.
Photo credit: DonkeyHotey/Flickr By Tobin Grant and Daniel Bennett U.S.
Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, who died unexpectedly Saturday (Feb. 14) approached the law with a clear (albeit controversial) jurisprudence on the First Amendment during his tenure on the high court. Scalia consistently argued that government could (and should) support religion. Over the past year, however, he adopted some unusual tactics to advocate for his position. REALLY? Scalia’s Resort Stay Was ‘Gift’ From ‘Friend’ Favored By SCOTUS Case Just Last Year - www.liberalamerica.org. It’s bad enough our current era throws enough chum to conspiracy theorists that the political waters of the early 21st century look like a piranha patch in a feeding frenzy without stories like this one: The late Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia seems to have died under suspicious circumstances, not because of whether or whether not he was killed by Obama, a heart attack, or natural causes, but because of where he died—at a posh resort in Texas, as a gift from “friend” who had benefited from a Supreme Court decision made in his favor only the year before.
Scalia was maxing and relaxing at the elite Cibolo Creek Ranch when LIFE, as they say, stepped in with other plans and the justice was found dead in his room Saturday morning. Who paid for Antonin Scalia's vacation to the luxury resort in Texas? On the heels of the news of Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia’s death, details have emerged about where he was staying when he passed away.
He was vacationing at the Cibolo Creek Ranch, a luxury resort offering “a true West Texas experience.” Guests enjoy trail rides via horse, ATV or Humvee around the massive 30,000 acre property. The ranch is also home to John B. Poindexter, owner of J.B. Poindexter & Company. I thought I could reason with Antonin Scalia: A more naive young fool never drew breath. In the two weeks since his death, many have spoken about Antonin Scalia’s undeniable impact on American law.
As attention shifts to filling the vacancy he has left on the Supreme Court, I would like instead to talk about his less appreciated impact on contemporary physics. But first, a bit of background. Antonin Scalia generally detested science. Supreme Court doctor: Scalia suffered from many health problems. A Texas sheriff's department released an incident report late Tuesday that revealed new details of the discovery of Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia's body, as well as the name of the friend who accompanied him on the hunting trip and the items found inside the ranch bedroom where the justice was found. In response to a public records request made by The Washington Post, the Presidio County Sheriff's Office released an incident report from the sheriff's investigation of Scalia's death at the Cibolo Creek Ranch on Feb. 13. The report stated that the justice's body was found in bed with a pillowcase covering his eyes. A breathing apparatus was on the table next to the bed, but it was switched off.