Google vs. Facebook

TwitterFacebook
Get flash to fully experience Pearltrees

[2010] Google To Facebook: You Can't Import Our User Data Any Longer Without Reciprocity

The war between Google and Facebook is heating up: Google just made one small tweak to its Terms of Service that will have a big impact on the world’s biggest social network. From now on, any service that accesses Google’s Contacts API — which makes it easy to import your list of friends’ and coworkers’ email addresses into another service — will need to offer reciprocity. http://techcrunch.com/2010/11/04/facebook-google-contacts/
http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/technology/2010/11/whats_mine_isnt_yours.html

The Facebook-Google spat over who controls your data. - By Farhad Manjoo - Slate Magazine

I don't think Google did everything right here, but it does clearly have the moral high ground. The search company has long been a champion of users' rights to transfer their data elsewhere. It even has an internal group, the Data Liberation Front , whose mission is to help all of Google's product teams build easy-to-use export features.

Zuckerberg admits fallibility over Gmail block • The Register

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2010/11/17/zuckerberg_on_google_api_spat/ Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg isn't sure that Facebook is "100 per cent right" in preventing Google's Gmail and other third-party apps from automatically importing email addresses from the social-networking service.
http://www.numerama.com/magazine/17356-mark-zuckerberg-doute-de-la-politique-de-fermeture-de-facebook.html Facebook va-t-il revoir sa politique en matière d'ouverture des données ? Invité au sommet Web 2.0 qui se déroule actuellement à San Francisco, le fondateur et directeur exécutif du réseau social a exprimé quelques doutes sur la politique de fermeture de son réseau social.

Mark Zuckerberg doute de la politique de fermeture de Facebook