
What is the rationale for foreign aid?
Get flash to fully experience Pearltrees
Making Aid More Effective: Lessons from the Philippines | In Asia
Pakistan, an Ally by Any Other Name | U.S. Naval Institute
Its ever-contentious relationship with America is unlikely to change, but the time is right for a reassessment of U.S. strategy in the region. The death of Osama bin Laden creates an opportunity for the United States to fundamentally re-examine its strategy in Afghanistan and South Asia. Such a re-evaluation must take into account three basic concepts: In addition, polling data suggest that public support for the United States in Pakistan is astonishingly low, civil-military relations are dominated by the military, and elements of the military support the Taliban along with a range of other Islamist militant groups.By the standards of some of the commentary that has appeared in the wake of the review of Australian aid, Hugh White’s op-ed in the Age is pretty good . Its tone is measured and it makes coherent points. Its central argument is plausible. And yet it is still wrong. It’s worth explaining why it is wrong, because the arguments it advances are conventional wisdom among many who comment on foreign aid, despite being mistaken. White’s case against aid runs like this:

